Home arrow Europe arrow Turkey & the EU
Turkey & the EU PDF Print E-mail
Written by Dominic Whiteman   
Sunday, 06 July 2008
Digg!
turkey-EU?A girl friend of mine was chatting at a party this summer. I overheard her talking about "men were all over me, even when I wore my hair under a scarf - groping me in public and pestering me in restaurants. Their dirty hands were everywhere. I suppose they thought I was Madonna or something."

As I approached her (careful to keep my distance) I asked her whether she was talking about India or Morocco, perhaps even Southern Italy - places, alas,  notorious for men of the groping variety.

I was surprised to hear my friend was talking about Turkey - the country where seventy women have protested this weekend after a court in Istanbul found a woman guilty of exhibitionism for fishing in what was termed "improper clothing". Fishermen complained that the attractive woman's skirt was flying up in the wind, as she suffered a Marilyn Monroe-esque wardrobe malfunction, and that this was - extraordinarily - "unacceptable" to them.

I someway - apparently erroneously - imagined that a country, albeit secular, with an Islamist ruling party and a President who showed up at the Euro 2008 finals with a headscarf-wearing wife (slightly less wrapped than Mrs Ahmedinejad and an altogether more colourful-looking Dalek) would frown upon scenes of civic groping by men and give gropers sharp lessons with severe punishments (the loss of a digit perhaps, or a public kneeing).

Not a bit of it apparently - she was publicly pestered by the local men from day one without any helpful intervention from members of the public or officials and her holiday was completely spoiled as a result. I was left thinking that the sexual mores of Turkey sounded as hypocritical as those of Saudi Arabia or Iran, where nothing goes according to theory but everything goes in practice as long as it is sanctioned (or ignored) by the relevant "religious" policemen who choose to uphold the nations' mores only when it suits them.

My visits to Turkey have been limited. One visit was to Istanbul to bring alive my study of the Byzantine Empire as a special subject at school. The other trip - to the resort of Marmaris - came after graduating from university. Both trips were enlightening and enjoyable - but then again I am not a ravishing blonde and the only time I was ever groped was in a rugby maul, which the groper didn't walk out of.

I remember friendly, gracious people when I was in Turkey - sunshine and monuments everywhere. I also remember that the food was rough (even by British standards back then, pre Oliver & Ramsay) and in one dish (a swordfish steak) I recall counting seven hairs (which beats even the hirsute eateries of twenty-first century Blackburn where one's fork might as well be a comb).

Those already in the EU who are against Turkey joining the EU - amongst other pretexts - come up with the old "culture clash" line and say we in the EU have nothing in common with a Muslim country who should look East not West. They point out the smouldering example of Germany where violence by and against Turkish immigrants has been rife - to such an extent perhaps, that before the recent Germany-Turkey match in the aforementioned Euro football finals, the two team captains were forced to read out avowals against racism after the national anthems after arriving on the pitch.

The anti Islamists would argue that letting one hundred million Muslims into Western Europe would be asking for trouble when the ones here already have hardly all integrated peacefully and successfully, let alone against the backcloth of a war on terror and global Islamist nuisance.

The question of Turkish EU membership is a complicated - Byzantinely complicated - one. First, there are all the Copenhagen criteria and various (seemingly shifting) economic hurdles to overcome. Then there are the varying improvements in democratisation and human rights demanded by EU members - particularly the decrease in military sway over Turkish governmental institutions. Then Turkey has critical member states and certain EU power blocs to overcome, not forgetting the Greek part of Cyprus which traditionally detests the Turks. Turkey is regularly accused of genocide in Armenia by even some major EU member states (like France) and - just as Turkish politicians get close to convincing Turks of EU membership - choice words from anti-Turkish membership protagonists seem to inflame the situation again.

There's a growing Turkish anger against the EU according to various Turkish commentators. One, writing in the Turkish Weekly, in late 2006, stated, "the never-ending EU demands have caused mass anger among the Turkish public. The pro-EU politicians have been exhausted by trying to answer the rightful questions of the people. The EU has been demanding without contributing anything to Turkey. The burden is getting heavier and heavier for pro-EU Turkish politicians and the Turkish Government without receiving any gains. As the pro-EU Turkish politicians have just convinced the public in favour of the EU, the EU says something on the Armenian or Cyprus issues in an extremely inconsiderate and anti-Turkish way. As a result, all the Turkish efforts are in vain. The anti-EU groups in Turkey, of course, abuse this situation as their mission. For these reasons, the EU process should be stopped in order to prevent a permanent hatred against the EU. By this way, the EU's ‘absurd' demands will stop, the Turkish politicians will not have to defend the EU membership, and the negative feelings among the public will have finished without growing into hatred and animosity against the EU."

Turkey seems to be losing patience. Or maybe they can hang around at the EU's gates until the green light eventually comes - one day.

Turkey's EU membership could contribute to the avoidance of a clash of civilisations according to the former and current British Foreign Secretaries - Jack Straw and David Milliband respectively. They have both argued that Turkey's participation could prove that the West is not solely a Christian Club and that the West could have a genuine cooperation with the Muslim world. By the EU embracing Turkey as a member of the EU, the West will be cocking a snook at Bin Laden and showing that, actually, Muslims and non Muslim Westerners can live together jolly happily and successfully. (Why the EU should react to the likes of Bin Laden in the first place is worrying - but anyway that is how their narrative goes.)

Several Muslim states have declared their full support for Turkey's EU membership. Saudia Arabia for example says "Turkey's EU membership is strategically important for Saudia Arabia". Iran, Syria, Egypt, Algeria, Indonesia and many others back Turkey's EU bid and say that Turkey would be the true representative of their countries in the EU. Libya's Qaddafi declared Turkey's joining the EU would be a great step forward for Muslim domination of Europe, though he was talking in his usual provocative way, as if there really was a world Ummah. (Turkey could probably do with all the above states just keeping quiet, as all of them, except perhaps Indonesia, qualify for the club of international pariahs).

Turkey unquestionably has a lot going for it. Turkey is the 17th largest economy in the world and it has achieved this success without EU membership. Several multi-nationals have dismantled their factories in Europe and moved them to Turkey because of cheaper labour costs. Turkey has strong tourism and industrial sectors. Apart from the conservative Islamist government, Turkey remains genuinely secular and buoyant in terms of typically Western creative success stories, like fashion and media. Its never-say-die football team performed heroically like Weeble men at Euro 2008 - even though its players are virtually unknown on the European football scene - and they won a succession of matches, snatching victory from the jaws of defeat on each occasion, before succumbing finally to a last minute goal by Germany. It's a country on the up, with growing national confidence, in spite of some of its leaders wanting to take it back to the Dark Ages.

So, what is the solution? A permanent "no" to Turkey EU membership or a straightforward "yes"?

The answer lies at the heart of Europe - with the old players of France and Germany and, alongside them, Britain. All three are suffering from the worst of Islamism within their own borders. They are all having problems trying to integrate minority Muslim populations heralding from lands far less secular in practice, and far more prone to extremism, than Turkey.

What Britain, Germany and France ought to do now is draft a new, scaled-down and relevant European constitution - one that addresses problems rather than addressing power-sourcing - with a portion to it that addresses the major problem of extreme Islamism and its ugly twin, Islamic terrorism. This portion should address the creeping problem of extreme Islamism in their own countries - in the extreme Islamist teaching and management of many Muslim faith schools, in creeping Sharia in the growing number of Sharia Councils, in the growth of anti-democratic Muslim political entities (especially on campus), in the increased subjugation of Muslim women (notably in British Pakistani neighbourhoods) and in the increased welfare dependence of Islamist groups and areas.

The Big Three should draw up a makeover list to nip in the bud the problem of extreme Islamism in their own back yards then tell Turkey it must address these issues head on or stay on the sidelines forever. Turkey must work to accept homosexuality, accept the equality of women, learn to tackle Islamist extremism in its own territory with panache and remove from office Khilafah-seeking Islamists in a return to the secularism of Kemal.

The Big Three should also tell Turkey that its economic hurdles were met years ago (if Greece and Romania managed entry, Turkey should stroll in), that its democratisation attempts have been admirable (and will naturally be spurred on by linking with the EU democratic machine), that it still needs to look at its human rights record (which is pretty awful compared to that of any current EU member state) and that its final test will be passed only when it grows up enough to consign Islamist political parties to history at General elections.  When Turkey joins, it must accept, sign and ratify through referendum the new constitution (and its counter Islamist extremism contents) clause by clause. This may take some time - so did the golden progress of 1924.

The Muslim communities in the world think that the West is not sincere in its struggle against terrorism and in its policies toward the Muslim world. There is a notable feeling of victimisation among Muslims generally. Extreme Islamist groups play on that and recruit supporters through their victim hood narrative.

The EU should be honest and bravely tell Turkey that certain aspects of its set-up stink, rather than pretending that its economy doesn't meet economic targets. The EU can tackle Islamist terrorism at both root and branch levels and send it packing at home, whilst embracing sensible, secular Muslims (like the majority of modern Turks), whilst the rest of the "Muslim" world looks on and Qaddafi has a reality check.

The EU carrot is too tempting for a country like Turkey which needs to get on. Turkey is likewise too tempting a carrot for the EU - a country which has the spirit, the economy, the population and the infrastructure to be a huge step forward for the EU generally.

There's a hovering fly soon to land in the soup: with its capital Istanbul due the biggest earthquake in its history over coming years.  For Istanbul is a city that straddles one of the most active seismic faultlines on the globe. A few miles away beneath the Marmara Sea, the North Anatolian fault line is stirring, virtually certain to rupture within a generation at the latest and bring much of Istanbul tumbling down. The EU will be a useful place for Turkey to be in the future - it's a generous club. The EU should rise with Turkey from its ashes (there will be plenty) and make sure that it rises with the ashes of extreme Islamism cast from its recent history forever too.

As for my friend and her gropers, I take her story with a pinch of salt - she tends to exaggerate and is often off the mark (once declaring that she saw a man "stabbed in the juggernaut"). Alas there are gropers everywhere, though especially in sexually repressed Muslim lands with their high share of hypocritical, conservative Islamists running the show.

Dominic Whiteman is Editor of the Westminster Journal & runs the pan-European V7 investigative network www.v7europe.com




Bookmark with:
Reddit!Del.icio.us!Google!Live!Facebook!Slashdot!Netscape!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Furl!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
 
< Prev   Next >
 

Westminster Journal

Stay updated. Subscribe to our service and get bi-monthly updated news.






channle4

Undercover Mosque: The Return

Britain's leading Muslim bodies say they are fighting extremism. In one of our most respected mosques, Sara Hassan came face to face with hardline female preachers of separatism. Here, she reports on the shocking results of her investigation: In a large balcony above the beautiful main hall at Regent's Park Mosque in London - widely considered the most important mosque in Britain - I am filming undercover as the woman...

Read more...
genesis islami

Genesis of Shi’a Islam

In order to understand the clerical rulers of Iran, we need to learn about the genesis of their religious faith, Shi'a Islam, and the pivotal place of the Mahdi. Examination of the vast Islamic literature shows that the present sect of Shi'a Islam has evolved from a mix of cultural, political, economic and religious influences. I shall outline, in a summary form, how the belief in the Mahdi, the revered...

Read more...
debunking myths of Islam

Debunking HT Myths

Last Saturday, while British athletes were getting on with their golden weekend at the Beijing Olympics (now known as the Great Haul of China) and most Brits were privately celebrating yet another reason to be British, virtually unnoticed the extreme Islamist cult Hizb ut Tahrir al Islami met publicly in a begrimed area of East London to hear various speakers discussing "Khilafah the need for political unity". Speakers present included...

Read more...
Musharraf

Musharraf Legacy?

Last week, on August 14th, Pakistan celebrated its Independence Day. Exactly 61 years previously, it had become autonomous, freed from British rule. At that time, under the leadership of Muhammad Ali Jinnah, Pakistan was officially secular. Jinnah died after only 13 months in power, and soon a succession of Islamist and military governments destroyed his ideal of a secular democracy. On August 14, 1947, Pakistan stretched beyond its current boundaries....

Read more...
Musharraf

Pakistan's Musharraf steps down

Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf, facing impeachment by parliament, has announced that he is resigning. In a national televised address he said he was confident the charges against him would not stand, but this was not the time for more confrontation. The charges against the president include violation of the constitution and gross misconduct. He has been one of the United States' strongest allies in its war against Islamist extremism. His...

Read more...
Iran's Mullahs

Iran Mullahs’ Blame Game

  It is a fundamental human trait to locate the source of anything bad happening and try to neutralize it. There are, however, times that the source of the harm cannot be pinpointed or when successfully recognized it cannot be eliminated. Failure to recognize the source or neutralize it is frustrating. And frustration triggers a variety of emotions and reactions. The feeling of victimization is one possible reaction that frequently...

Read more...
Iran's Mullahs

Iran Mullahs’ Blame Game

  It is a fundamental human trait to locate the source of anything bad happening and try to neutralize it. There are, however, times that the source of the harm cannot be pinpointed or when successfully recognized it cannot be eliminated. Failure to recognize the source or neutralize it is frustrating. And frustration triggers a variety of emotions and reactions. The feeling of victimization is one possible reaction that frequently...

Read more...
atheist ban

Atheist Website Ban

A city council has blocked its staff from looking at websites about atheism. Lawyers at the National Secular Society said the move by Birmingham City Council was "discriminatory" and they would consider legal action. The rules also ban sites that promote witchcraft, the paranormal, sexual deviancy and criminal activity. The city council declined to comment on the possible legal action, but said the new system helped make it easier for...

Read more...
hamas

How Britain Helps Hamas And The Muslim Brotherhood - Part 2

In Britain, the Muslim Brotherhood has made its presence felt through its front groups and individuals who play double roles in society. The Muslim Association of Britain (MAB) is widely perceived as a front-group of the Muslim Brotherhood. It was co-founded in 1997 by Kemal el-Helbawy the European spokesman of the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood. In 2004, at the invitation of the MAB, the Muslim Brotherhood's "spiritual leader", Sheikh Yusuf al-Qaradawi,...

Read more...
hamas

How Britain Helps Hamas and the Muslim Brotherhood: Part One of Two

This week, the annual British event known as "Islam Expo" came to a close. In 2006, this "celebration" of Islamic heritage and identity gathered criticism as the event - then held in Alexandra Palace in North London - took place while relatives were commemorating the first anniversary of the 7/7 attacks. Additionally, some of the proposed speakers at that 2006 event were known to hold extremist views. One of these...

Read more...
86 wives

86 wives

Nigerian Mohammed Bello Abubakar, 84, has advised other men not to follow his example and marry 86 women. The former teacher and Muslim preacher, who lives in Niger State with his wives and at least 170 children, says he is able to cope only with the help of God. "A man with 10 wives would collapse and die, but my own power is given by Allah. That is why I...

Read more...
hell OK

The Attractive Alternative of Hell

I was baptised two weeks into my life then confirmed a Roman Catholic at fourteen. I don't proselytise. I turn down most invitations outside of mass to church events and only bother God when I need to, or I think it's time. I would never vote under pressure from my so-called religious leaders. I am a secularist but would never join a secularist society. I've been called a Papist, a...

Read more...
Brown

Brown Down & Out

The Scottish National Party has pulled off a stunning by-election victory by winning Glasgow East, one of Labour's safest seats, by 365 votes. The SNP overturned a Labour majority of 13,507 to win with a swing of 22.54%. The SNP polled 11,277 votes in the contest, while the Tories came third with 1,639 and the Lib Dems, with 915 votes, came fourth. SNP candidate John Mason said the victory was...

Read more...
Brown

Brown Down & Out

The Scottish National Party has pulled off a stunning by-election victory by winning Glasgow East, one of Labour's safest seats, by 365 votes. The SNP overturned a Labour majority of 13,507 to win with a swing of 22.54%. The SNP polled 11,277 votes in the contest, while the Tories came third with 1,639 and the Lib Dems, with 915 votes, came fourth. SNP candidate John Mason said the victory was "off the Richter scale". Voter turnout...

Read more...
Brown

Brown Down & Out

The Scottish National Party has pulled off a stunning by-election victory by winning Glasgow East, one of Labour's safest seats, by 365 votes. The SNP overturned a Labour majority of 13,507 to win with a swing of 22.54%. The SNP polled 11,277 votes in the contest, while the Tories came third with 1,639 and the Lib Dems, with 915 votes, came fourth. SNP candidate John Mason said the victory was "off the Richter scale". Voter turnout...

Read more...
Brown

Brown Down & Out

The Scottish National Party has pulled off a stunning by-election victory by winning Glasgow East, one of Labour's safest seats, by 365 votes. The SNP overturned a Labour majority of 13,507 to win with a swing of 22.54%. The SNP polled 11,277 votes in the contest, while the Tories came third with 1,639 and the Lib Dems, with 915 votes, came fourth. SNP candidate John Mason said the victory was "off the Richter scale". Voter turnout...

Read more...
internet threats

Attacks begin on net address flaw

Attack code that exploits flaws in the net's addressing system are starting to circulate online, say security experts. The code could be a boon to phishing gangs who redirect web users to fake bank sites and steal login details. In light of the news net firms are being urged to apply a fix for the loop-hole before attacks by hi-tech criminals become widespread. Net security groups say there is anecdotal...

Read more...
UK chief judge

Are British Muslims Treated Like Jews in 1930s Germany?

On Jews, Muslims and Hitler Yesterday - Monday July 7, 2008 - was the third anniversary of the suicide bombings on London Transport. Mohammed Sidique Khan, Shehzad Tanweer and Jermaine Lindsay blew themselves up on underground trains, while Hasib Hossain boarded a Number 30 bus and detonated his rucksack in Tavistock Square. 52 people were killed and hundreds were injured. On British television, a documentary was broadcast on Channel 4,...

Read more...
Qatada

Qatada Bad Back Benefits

The fanatical cleric, said to be Osama Bin Laden's ambassador in Europe, will get £150 a week of taxpayer's cash after being released from jail in mid June. He was granted the incapacity benefit because his condition makes him unfit to work - even though a curfew allows him out of his home for only two hours a day, meaning it would be almost impossible for him to get a...

Read more...
prisoner convenant

Prisoner Covenant?

An Algerian suspected of links to Osama bin Laden and bomb plots in the United States and France has been freed from a British prison after more than seven years but placed under house arrest while he fights deportation. The 45-year-old man was released under bail conditions, made public last Thursday, which restrict him to a single, undisclosed address and state that he "shall remain in the residence at all...

Read more...